Your top 10 pubs

[Mobyduck]

I'm biased as I can't abide cucumbers but I love pickled gherkins. Weird or what?

Weird!!!

Yep.

[london calling]

I quite like that beer, weird or what.

Bought a bottle of that beer on my birthday as I like it as well.

[Quinno]

So - is there a list of pubs from all the Top 10's which we can all see? I can't be arsed to tot them all up if two others already have!

[sheffield hatter]

So - is there a list of pubs from all the Top 10's which we can all see? I can't be arsed to tot them all up if two others already have!

Aqualung and I agreed (see posts #84 & #85) to leave it until the end of January to reveal the top nominated pubs.

[Aqualung]

Aqualung and I agreed (see posts #84 & #85) to leave it until the end of January to reveal the top nominated pubs.

Ahead of that, I've got two on 5 votes, five on 4 votes, fifteen on 3 votes and twenty five on 2 votes. there are 282 votes.

[NickDavies]

Ahead of that, I've got two on 5 votes, five on 4 votes, fifteen on 3 votes and twenty five on 2 votes. there are 282 votes.

How will you achieve a rank order within each group? Average point score?

[Aqualung]

How will you achieve a rank order within each group? Average point score?

I don't envisage any ranking my list is in alphabetical order. The problem with using ranking is how far do go back. A re-incarnated pub may have poor scores from the previous incarnation. I've already been to two places this year that I would have had to at least consider! I can't make up my mind which should be POTM for January.

[sheffield hatter]

Ahead of that, I've got two on 5 votes, five on 4 votes, fifteen on 3 votes and twenty five on 2 votes. there are 282 votes.

I've got 48 on two or more, with the number of twos 26 rather than your 25. Have you missed Ye Olde Mitre from Blackthorn's list that was also nominated previously by Rex Rattus?

[sheffield hatter]

How will you achieve a rank order within each group? Average point score?

I've used average points scores, though obviously they're not meant to be taken too seriously. I've used the average at the time the pub was nominated and I'm not going through 203 pubs again to make sure they haven't changed since...

[Aqualung]

I've got 48 on two or more, with the number of twos 26 rather than your 25. Have you missed Ye Olde Mitre from Blackthorn's list that was also nominated previously by Rex Rattus?

My list of pubs which I had updated manually was correct apart from miscounting the number with 2 votes. I had errors in my spreadsheet due to two "e"s in Bretforton and a missing "e" in Ye Olde Mitre. It all now tallies and I agree with your totals.