I can recall visits to The London Apprentice,Cittie of York,Olde Mitre and the Blackfriar but have only reviewed the latter so it's been a while for the others.
Printable View
I think I have been to all except the Beehive in Barnes due to it being closed, The French House as I probably thought it was a restaurant and the Wine Shades.
Ive done 6 on the list all after 2004,London Apprentice,The Salisbury,Red Lion,Bunch of Grapes,Cittie of York and ye Olde Mitre Inn
I had a look at The Old Wine Shades and decided not to do it, and i did attempt to do Jack Straws Castle but it had already closed down.
Three for me
The Salisbury, Cittie of York and ye Olde Mitre Inn.
The Blackfriars has long been on my list and I'll add the Red Lion.
Five for me,Salisbury,Red lion,Cittie of York,Blackfriar and Olde Mitre.
The 2016 Good Food Guide includes a list of it's top 50 pubs, although one assumes that will be based on the food being served and hence may not correspond with the views of the regulars on this forum.
http://www.thegoodfoodguide.co.uk/news/2016-top-50-pubs
Regretably, as someone who enjoys eating good meals in pubs as well as driniking beer in them, I have only been to two, The Pony & Trap and The Hinds Head. The Kingham Plough is definitely on my "to do" list though.