Boak and Bailey's Beer Blog - Utopians vs. Sentimentalists

Visit the Boak and Bailey's Beer Blog site

Boak & Bailey's Beer Blog - Writing about beer and pubs since 2007
In 1925, Swiss-born architect Le Corbusier, a pioneer of modern architecture,*proposed that the historic centre of Paris be flattened and replaced with a set of identical tower blocks set in a grid.

All those old buildings, narrow winding roads and quaint features were, in his view, ‘rustic bric-a-brac’ and needed to be swept away so that order could be achieved. With order, he argued, would come true human happiness, if only people would look inside themselves and realise that’s what they really wanted. (Which sounds slightly scary to modern ears.)
His extreme philosophy, abstracted from practical concerns, sits on*one side of an ideological battle still being played out across all fields of human activity: Logic or sentiment? Machines or men? Straight lines or wonky ones? Industry or craft?
At about the same time as his ideas had filtered through to*inform the planning and design of post-war British cities (see Plymouth, for example)*another expression of the logic/machines/straight-lines way of thinking was also underway:*the Big Six project in British brewing.
Whitbread, Watney’s, et al,*became seduced by a Utopian vision*of pure efficiency. They rejected the idea of lots of*little breweries all over the place in favour of big ones in central locations, connected by motorway.
They decided computer-control was the way forward, reducing the opportunities for human interference to introduce inconsistency into the product.
Tradition*was a nuisance — something to be ‘got over’.

It is with tinges of regret that we witness the disappearance of the traditional brewer wandering around the brewery with only his sensitive nose, keen palate and a few basic scientific instruments to guide him… [as] we move to a new generation of white-coated technicians bristling with scientific qualifications, guided in their work by panels of flickering lights…

H.A. Monckton,*A History of English Ale & Beer, 1966

The Society for the Preservation of Beers from the Wood (SPBW), Campaign for Real Ale (CAMRA), the pub preservation movement, and ‘micro brewing’, all stood, and still stand, on the side*of*sentimentality and ‘the human touch’.*Greenleaf*over*Ironsides.
And in marketing terms, the sentimentalists have won — we don’t think many breweries these days would invite the press to see their computers, as did Whitbread at Luton in May 1969, or use an image like this one from Boddington’s, c.1978, in promotional*materials:
http://boakandbailey.com/wp-content/...puter_1978.jpg
But most people don’t feel that strongly either way*– they’re turned off by automation, but expect a certain level of consistency; they appreciate the fruits of efficiency, but don’t want to see old pubs or breweries knocked down to achieve it. They are, in short, pragmatic.
But pragmatism, as far as people like Le Corbusier are concerned, is synonymous with compromise — the worst of both worlds.
Excuse us thinking aloud. We’re working on something — a longer article, or maybe a video — about flat-roofed, cube-like post-war ‘modern’ pubs, which is why we happen to be reading outside our*usual territory.
Utopians vs. Sentimentalists


More...