Yes, it's not easy, is it! (I've been to eight of your 10 and know the other two by reputation or recommendation, so applaud your choices.)
It's made even harder for me by the fact I've only ever awarded eight scores of 10. Going through those and my slightly more numerous nines, I recognise quite a few instances where I've been influenced by an emotional reaction to the pub: being bowled over. Most of these are pubs that have scored highly for what was a very brief visit and that, on reflection, may not have been as good as I thought they were. But if I've only been there once, who can tell?
So, with reservations as above, here's my Top 10:
Talbot Arms, Settle
Yew Tree, Cauldon
Blake Hotel, Sheffield
Manor Arms, Broughton in Furness
Fox & Goose, Hebden Bridge
Pelican Inn, Gloucester
Barrels, Berwick upon Tweed
Brunswick Inn, Derby
Globe, Dunstable
Barley Mow, Kirk Ireton
Victoria, Great Harwood
Oops, miscounted. That's 11!