Blog Tracker
22-01-2024, 13:50
Visit The Pub Curmudgeon site (https://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2024/01/union-busting.html)
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEghIDaFtfSkPXzVOMI_OwqB-w25rhcAhqCxhVeH9H-bWYsRWYUTlO6_-KCjcsrl8JwhQsqeQGLVGjALYJTmVvj5v8INARFNadgqY5fzgfR BXv_cB4lIOC5RsLuWQkH_oGZnWC6voyhYjGvLVOgZtgdkQOJx4 AKt9IRWC7eZmMWtr84qg0SskiJ5Vpg3RXM/s200/Pedigree%20change.jpg (https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEghIDaFtfSkPXzVOMI_OwqB-w25rhcAhqCxhVeH9H-bWYsRWYUTlO6_-KCjcsrl8JwhQsqeQGLVGjALYJTmVvj5v8INARFNadgqY5fzgfR BXv_cB4lIOC5RsLuWQkH_oGZnWC6voyhYjGvLVOgZtgdkQOJx4 AKt9IRWC7eZmMWtr84qg0SskiJ5Vpg3RXM/s768/Pedigree%20change.jpg)
The Morning Advertiser reports that Carlsberg-Marston’s have decided to discontinue the use of traditional “Union sets” (https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2024/01/19/cmbc-retiring-union-sets-at-marston-s-brewery) for brewing Marston’s Pedigree. This is a distinctive fermentation system, described here (https://beerandbrewing.com/dictionary/IdBjsaZjWz/), which uses large wooden casks to recirculate the beer. This was met with predictable outrage about the destruction of Britain’s brewing heritage.
However, it must be remembered that Carlsberg-Marston’s are a commercial company, not the custodians of a brewing museum. Using Union sets is considerably more expensive than conventional fermenters, and they must have decided that any additional cachet conferred by this system no longer counts for much in the beer market. Yes, it is sad, but no more sad than the closure of innumerable breweries over the years. Change inevitably involves a sense of loss.
In the early days of CAMRA, Pedigree was revered as one of the top beers in the country. I remember when I was at University in Birmingham in the late 70s going on a trip into the Worcestershire countryside and being told, on entering a Marston’s pub, “Pedigree’s the one to go for here.” I have a copy of Michael Jackson’s Pocket Beer Book from as late as 1995 in which he gives it four stars as a world classic, and praises its “clean, dry, gently fruity, nutty character”, although I think by then it was already trading on past glories.
But, over the years, for whatever reason, it lost its allure. Possibly expanding its distribution and exposing it to more poor cellarmanship was a factor. In the 1980s it was made available in many Whtibread pubs, where it was often found in poor condition. The bitter takeover battle with Wolverhampton & Dudley in the early 2000s can’t have helped either. This ended up with Wolves triumphant, but not too longer after assuming the more widely recognised identity of their target.
Quite a few people on Twitter have made comments along the lines of “I haven’t had a good pint in twenty years”, or “it’s just dishwater now”. Sadly, it seems to be widely dismissed as being just another boring brown beer to file alongside Doom Bar and Greene King IPA. It seems to be one of those beers, like Landlord, that needs a decent amount of conditioning time in the cellar and, if it’s served too green, just ends up being muddy and bland.
To be honest, it’s always been one of my favourite beers, and one that I tend to go for if I see it, which isn’t that often now. I don’t record every single beer I drink, but looking back through my notes, it seems that the last time I had it was in October last year in the Crown in Market Drayton, where I described it as “surprisingly good” and gave it an NBSS score of 3.5. I remember a particularly good pint in the Bank House in Uttoxeter (https://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2019/06/in-land-of-bass-and-pedi.html) in June 2019, where it was the best beer of the day. But I have to say that in recent years Draught Bass, also now brewed by Marston’s, although not in the Union sets, has been a consistently better beer. The results of this Twitter poll suggests that most drinkers have now largely forgotten about it.
POLL: When did you last drink a pint of Marston’s Pedigree?
— Pub Curmudgeon 🌸🍻 (@oldmudgie) January 20, 2024 (https://twitter.com/oldmudgie/status/1748617812120137869?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw) Mention of Bass recalls the fact that they closed their much larger union sets back in 1981, to the accompaniment of a considerable amount of criticism, although back in those days the beer and pub industry in general was in much ruder health, and Bass were derided as one of the “Big Six”. It was widely felt that Draught Bass was never the same again.
But it is significant that no other brewery has sought to create union sets, suggesting they aren’t really an essential element of brewing a high-quality beer. There are plenty of beers in the UK that are currently rated more highly than Pedigree, none of which are brewed using unions. Indeed most Pedigree itself is not brewed in unions, with a proportion of union-brewed beer being blended in at the end of the process. So the system was, to be honest, something of an anachronism, described in the article I linked to above as “an anomaly”.
Beer writer Adrian Tierney-Jones has stated on Twitter that “I’m amazed it lasted this long given the rapacious nature of global brewing.” Whether the unions would have lasted longer if Marston’s had still been in sole charge is debatable, but once the merger with Carlsberg took place it was probably inevitable sooner or later. This was in effect a shotgun wedding forced on Marston’s by their heavily indebted state, which was dangerously exposed by the impact of lockdowns. This in turn was largely the result of the mutually destructive takeover battle with Wolverhampton & Dudley back in the 2000s.
It was clear from the beginning that Carlsberg held the upper hand, and they have proceeded with a process of rationalisation, involving selling off the Bedford brewery and closing Jennings, Ringwood and Wychwood. Indeed there must be a question mark over how long they will retain two large ale breweries fairly close together in the Midlands at Burton and Wolverhampton.
Obviously the two cases are very different, but there are certain parallels with the reaction to the destruction of the Crooked House pub, where many people suddenly discovered reserves of anger about the end of something that they hadn’t particularly cared about while it was in existence.
More... (https://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2024/01/union-busting.html)
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEghIDaFtfSkPXzVOMI_OwqB-w25rhcAhqCxhVeH9H-bWYsRWYUTlO6_-KCjcsrl8JwhQsqeQGLVGjALYJTmVvj5v8INARFNadgqY5fzgfR BXv_cB4lIOC5RsLuWQkH_oGZnWC6voyhYjGvLVOgZtgdkQOJx4 AKt9IRWC7eZmMWtr84qg0SskiJ5Vpg3RXM/s200/Pedigree%20change.jpg (https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEghIDaFtfSkPXzVOMI_OwqB-w25rhcAhqCxhVeH9H-bWYsRWYUTlO6_-KCjcsrl8JwhQsqeQGLVGjALYJTmVvj5v8INARFNadgqY5fzgfR BXv_cB4lIOC5RsLuWQkH_oGZnWC6voyhYjGvLVOgZtgdkQOJx4 AKt9IRWC7eZmMWtr84qg0SskiJ5Vpg3RXM/s768/Pedigree%20change.jpg)
The Morning Advertiser reports that Carlsberg-Marston’s have decided to discontinue the use of traditional “Union sets” (https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2024/01/19/cmbc-retiring-union-sets-at-marston-s-brewery) for brewing Marston’s Pedigree. This is a distinctive fermentation system, described here (https://beerandbrewing.com/dictionary/IdBjsaZjWz/), which uses large wooden casks to recirculate the beer. This was met with predictable outrage about the destruction of Britain’s brewing heritage.
However, it must be remembered that Carlsberg-Marston’s are a commercial company, not the custodians of a brewing museum. Using Union sets is considerably more expensive than conventional fermenters, and they must have decided that any additional cachet conferred by this system no longer counts for much in the beer market. Yes, it is sad, but no more sad than the closure of innumerable breweries over the years. Change inevitably involves a sense of loss.
In the early days of CAMRA, Pedigree was revered as one of the top beers in the country. I remember when I was at University in Birmingham in the late 70s going on a trip into the Worcestershire countryside and being told, on entering a Marston’s pub, “Pedigree’s the one to go for here.” I have a copy of Michael Jackson’s Pocket Beer Book from as late as 1995 in which he gives it four stars as a world classic, and praises its “clean, dry, gently fruity, nutty character”, although I think by then it was already trading on past glories.
But, over the years, for whatever reason, it lost its allure. Possibly expanding its distribution and exposing it to more poor cellarmanship was a factor. In the 1980s it was made available in many Whtibread pubs, where it was often found in poor condition. The bitter takeover battle with Wolverhampton & Dudley in the early 2000s can’t have helped either. This ended up with Wolves triumphant, but not too longer after assuming the more widely recognised identity of their target.
Quite a few people on Twitter have made comments along the lines of “I haven’t had a good pint in twenty years”, or “it’s just dishwater now”. Sadly, it seems to be widely dismissed as being just another boring brown beer to file alongside Doom Bar and Greene King IPA. It seems to be one of those beers, like Landlord, that needs a decent amount of conditioning time in the cellar and, if it’s served too green, just ends up being muddy and bland.
To be honest, it’s always been one of my favourite beers, and one that I tend to go for if I see it, which isn’t that often now. I don’t record every single beer I drink, but looking back through my notes, it seems that the last time I had it was in October last year in the Crown in Market Drayton, where I described it as “surprisingly good” and gave it an NBSS score of 3.5. I remember a particularly good pint in the Bank House in Uttoxeter (https://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2019/06/in-land-of-bass-and-pedi.html) in June 2019, where it was the best beer of the day. But I have to say that in recent years Draught Bass, also now brewed by Marston’s, although not in the Union sets, has been a consistently better beer. The results of this Twitter poll suggests that most drinkers have now largely forgotten about it.
POLL: When did you last drink a pint of Marston’s Pedigree?
— Pub Curmudgeon 🌸🍻 (@oldmudgie) January 20, 2024 (https://twitter.com/oldmudgie/status/1748617812120137869?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw) Mention of Bass recalls the fact that they closed their much larger union sets back in 1981, to the accompaniment of a considerable amount of criticism, although back in those days the beer and pub industry in general was in much ruder health, and Bass were derided as one of the “Big Six”. It was widely felt that Draught Bass was never the same again.
But it is significant that no other brewery has sought to create union sets, suggesting they aren’t really an essential element of brewing a high-quality beer. There are plenty of beers in the UK that are currently rated more highly than Pedigree, none of which are brewed using unions. Indeed most Pedigree itself is not brewed in unions, with a proportion of union-brewed beer being blended in at the end of the process. So the system was, to be honest, something of an anachronism, described in the article I linked to above as “an anomaly”.
Beer writer Adrian Tierney-Jones has stated on Twitter that “I’m amazed it lasted this long given the rapacious nature of global brewing.” Whether the unions would have lasted longer if Marston’s had still been in sole charge is debatable, but once the merger with Carlsberg took place it was probably inevitable sooner or later. This was in effect a shotgun wedding forced on Marston’s by their heavily indebted state, which was dangerously exposed by the impact of lockdowns. This in turn was largely the result of the mutually destructive takeover battle with Wolverhampton & Dudley back in the 2000s.
It was clear from the beginning that Carlsberg held the upper hand, and they have proceeded with a process of rationalisation, involving selling off the Bedford brewery and closing Jennings, Ringwood and Wychwood. Indeed there must be a question mark over how long they will retain two large ale breweries fairly close together in the Midlands at Burton and Wolverhampton.
Obviously the two cases are very different, but there are certain parallels with the reaction to the destruction of the Crooked House pub, where many people suddenly discovered reserves of anger about the end of something that they hadn’t particularly cared about while it was in existence.
More... (https://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2024/01/union-busting.html)