PDA

View Full Version : The Pub Curmudgeon - Minimum madness



Blog Tracker
01-05-2018, 14:45
Visit The Pub Curmudgeon site (http://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2018/05/minimum-madness.html)


Well, minimum alcohol pricing has finally arrived in Scotland today. There’s not a great deal I can add to the points I made here (http://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.co.uk/2017/11/minimum-effectiveness.html) and here (http://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.co.uk/2017/11/more-minimum-pricing-thoughts.html), although I have produced a summary of the issue (https://curmudgeoncolumns.blogspot.co.uk/2018/05/mayjune-2018.html) for my Opening Times column.
Despite all the publicity, a lot of people are going to be taken by surprise when they go to the supermarket. The policy has been touted as something to address the scourge of “high-strength, low-cost alcohol”, but in reality it will affect well over half of all alcohol sold in the off-trade. Many consumers of mainstream products such as multipacks of lager and litre bottles of spirits will receive a shock. This news report (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-43891989) lists some of the significant price increases that will occur.
This is a point made by Gordon Johncox of Aston Manor in a report in Drinks Retailing News (http://drinksretailingnews.co.uk/news/fullstory.php/aid/17679/Scotland_s_minimum_unit_pricing_plan_is__unmerited __and__unlikely_to_work_.html), where he says:

The forecast model for MUP significantly underestimates how much moderate drinkers will be out of pocket based on real-world experience and actual market data. If the level and pattern of drinking were to remain unchanged after 1st May, then it would cost drinkers in Scotland in the order of £150 million a year.He also reiterates the point I have made before that, far from giving the on-trade a boost, it will if anything harm it, as people’s disposable incomes are affected.

Counter to the view that is often repeated and promoted, MUP will reduce spending in pubs and bars. Representing as it does a regressive cost on even moderate drinkers, the increased cost on such a wide range of drinks will reduce the spending of consumers in pubs. This is clear in the forecast model, yet is not referenced or highlighted (even by the researchers that formulated the forecast model).However, despite this, the appeasers of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association (http://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.co.uk/2018/03/och-aye-what-nice-crocodile.html), and many useful idiots within CAMRA, still cling to the idea that it will in some way be good news for pubs. However, at heart I suspect they don’t really believe it will bring any benefit, and are embracing it purely out of a spiteful, dog-in-the-manner spirit of doing down another section of the drinks trade that they perceive as the enemy.
Obviously it will take some time before the effects of the policy can be properly assessed. No doubt there will be a short-term drop in apparent alcohol consumption, but the headline figure will inevitably be affected both by drinkers stocking up before May 1st, and buying alcohol in England afterwards.
The Scottish Goverment have gone on record as saying they don’t think there will be a significant amount of cross-border shopping. It’s certainly true that the distances between the major population centres in Scotland and the Border are such that you can’t just nip across for a few cans – Glasgow is 99 miles from Carlisle, and Edinburgh 56 miles from Berwick. But, every time any Scottish resident crosses the border for any reason in the normal course of their life, there will be a strong incentive to pick up some cans and bottles both for themselves and their friends and relatives. With potential savings of at least a fiver on a slab of Carling and a litre bottle of Bell’s, a nice little afternoon drive down the A1 to Berwick for four mates every month will pay for itself many times over.
And, inevitably, the calls will now intensify for the policy to be extended to England (https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/calls-england-introduce-minimum-pricing-14596263)...


More... (http://pubcurmudgeon.blogspot.com/2018/05/minimum-madness.html)