View Full Version : Boak and Bailey's Beer Blog - How Come Nobody Criticises That Rosé de Gambrinus Label

Blog Tracker
08-02-2018, 21:10
Visit the Boak and Bailey's Beer Blog site (https://boakandbailey.com/2018/02/how-come-nobody-criticises-that-rose-de-gambrinus-label/)

We admit it: the rhetorical “Where’s the outrage?” winds us up. What it so often means is, because you forgot to mention This, you must now shut up about That, AKA*‘whataboutery (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/whataboutery)’ — a means of shutting down rather than adding to an ongoing discussion.
In relation to beer we’ve seen this argument rolled out a few times lately as part of the renewed discussion around sexist beer labels. Here’s the latest nod in that direction (a very mild one, it must be said, and hardly malicious) which directly prompted us to post today:

the elephant in the room… pic.twitter.com/OA4KMXgbcV (https://t.co/OA4KMXgbcV)
— Yeastie Boys (@yeastieboys) February 7, 2018 (https://twitter.com/yeastieboys/status/961250388346310656?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw)

Yes, always found it a bit odd that people curiously forget to talk about that one.
— Samogotchi (@samogotchi) February 7, 2018 (https://twitter.com/samogotchi/status/961250831571054593?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw)

At this point, we chipped in: people do*talk about this label. We’ve seen them do it.*We were involved in a Twitter discussion about it ourselves just before Christmas* prompted, of course, by someone asking (https://twitter.com/GoodBeerTweet/status/936884389044092929)*“Why is nobody complaining about Cantillon’s classic Rosé de Gambrinus woman getting touched up on a bench?”
It also featured in this widely shared 2015 list of sexist beer labels from Thrillist (https://www.thrillist.com/drink/nation/sexist-beer-labels-and-names-in-craft-beer); was mentioned in passing by Natalya Watson (https://watsonscorner.beer/2017/01/12/cantillon-rose-de-gambrinus/) in a well-read blog post in January 2017;* has been picked up by Mike from Chorlton Brewing on a couple of occasions, e.g. here (https://twitter.com/ChorltonBrew/status/879007744719806466); and it has frequently come up in discussion at Beer Advocate and RateBeer. People have noticed it and aren’t 100 per cent comfortable; it has not sailed beneath the radar.
But, yes, it’s true it isn’t one of the top beers on the hit list, and we can’t find any really impassioned posts by any of our fellow beer bloggers calling for that particular label to change or be removed from shelves.
In fact if you go back far enough you’ll find various people sticking up for it and, indeed, citing criticism of the label as evidence of humourless puritanism. Here’s Jay Brooks of*Brookston Beer Bulletin (http://brookstonbeerbulletin.com/the-santa-hypocrisy/), for example, writing in 2006 about US censorship of the RDG label: “I cringe every time I think what prudes we are as a nation and how ridiculous we must seem to the rest of the civilized world.” Here’s the one that will probably most surprise people, though: Melissa Cole saying something quite similar a decade ago (http://www.letmetellyouaboutbeer.co.uk/2008/02/up-skirt-quangos.html). It’s so at odds with Melissa’s current stance that we felt compelled to ask her about it via Twitter DM:

I was wrong. I also didn’t realise it was a pattern of wider misogyny in the naming of the beers at Cantillon, I only found out what Fou’ Foune meant relatively recently and given that they are happy to change their mind for commercial reasons in the US, how about they change their minds for the sake of coming into the 21st century too?
I was probably also a bit worried about taking aim at one of the ‘untouchables’ as well. At that time I had taken about six months of quite serious stick and was being denied information and quotes by a cabal of brewers who were closing ranks and trying to keep me quiet by making it very difficult to do my job – fortunately most of them have now retired or folded.
I’ve never claimed to be a perfect person or a perfect feminist (if either of those things actually exist!) and I’m happy to say I got that one wrong and I’ve been quite happy to be vocal that it needs changing recently partly because I don’t worry about being bullied any more and partly because, even if people do come at me, I feel I’ve got a far better way to communicate my points these days – a decade of challenging issues of inequality in the industry, even imperfectly, will do that for you!
The bar has clearly moved and the boundaries are continuing to change. Things that seemed fine a decade ago, or even a couple of years back, have acquired an unpleasant stink. The Rosé de Gambrinus label isn’t violent or sweaty; it’s so soft it seems almost abstract; and the beer doesn’t have a baldly suggestive name to go with the picture. In 2018, though, none of that quite washes, and we suspect there will be more direct criticism of Cantillon in the next year or two. And, yes, we suspect Cantillon probably were given a bit of a pass because they are cool, interesting and mysterious in a way microbreweries in middle England rarely are.
But it does seem to us that we’re reaching a point where there are (per Melissa’s very honest admission) no longer any untouchables, and rightly so, at least in part because of people asking*“Where’s the outrage?”
In the meantime remember, if you think this label or that is particularly nasty, there’s nothing stopping*you from writing about it. You don’t have to wait for Melissa or Matt Curtis to do it.

* * * Having said all that, there are plenty of good reasons why British commentators might choose to concentrate on British beers. First, this is our turf and we feel entitled to a say in what goes on here, whereas it feels somehow presumptuous to put pressure on brewers operating in different countries or cultures.
Secondly, as consumers and commentators in this ecosystem, we stand a faint chance of influencing the decisions of brewers and retailers, so it feels worth the bother. Or, to put that another way, the folk at Castle Rock might just care what we and others think, whereas we doubt the aloof enigmas of Cantillon, who can’t brew enough beer to meet global demand, give a flying one. If someone did want to pressure them, how would they do it? When Cloudwater drops a clanger its Twitter feed blows up; Cantillon isn’t on Twitter, and is barely on Facebook.
Finally, there’s the fact that Rosé de Gambrinus might as well not exist in our world. We don’t remember the last time we had it or saw it for sale, and if we did we probably wouldn’t want to pay the asking price. For us, and probably for many other, it simply doesn’t come to mind. Teignworthy Bristol’s Ale or Castle Rock Elsie Mo, on the other hand, are beers we have actually encountered in a pub in the last month.

* * * There’s also, of course, an argument for not mentioning particular breweries at all. There’s not much here that can’t be discussed in terms of general principles, is there?
How Come Nobody Criticises That Rosé de Gambrinus Label? (https://boakandbailey.com/2018/02/how-come-nobody-criticises-that-rose-de-gambrinus-label/) originally posted at Boak & Bailey's Beer Blog (https://boakandbailey.com)

More... (https://boakandbailey.com/2018/02/how-come-nobody-criticises-that-rose-de-gambrinus-label/)