PDA

View Full Version : Shut up about Barclay Perkins - City of London Pale Ale quality 1922 - 1925



Blog Tracker
07-04-2014, 08:13
Visit the Shut up about Barclay Perkins site (http://barclayperkins.blogspot.com/2014/04/city-of-london-pale-ale-quality-1922.html)


http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-iaqyBk53JYo/Uz1Ns-p9qeI/AAAAAAAATS0/BtRXmqh_Pzg/s1600/Wood_&_Watson_Pale_Ale.jpg (http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-iaqyBk53JYo/Uz1Ns-p9qeI/AAAAAAAATS0/BtRXmqh_Pzg/s1600/Wood_&_Watson_Pale_Ale.jpg)
First a quick recap. City of London's Mild was dreadful, with a score of -1.25. Their Burton fared a little better, coming on with a just positive 0.09.

You can see that we have here an 8d per pint (falling to 7d in 1923) Ordinary Bitter. It's almost spot on in its specs for an average beer of its type. Which was around 1046, 4.8% ABV and 80% apparent attenuation. I think that's a clear indication that Whitbread wasn't the only brewery keeping a close eye on its competitors.

It's noticeable that Whitbread took many more samples in times of uncertainty and change. There are loads from the early and mid 1920's, when British beer was starting to take its post-war form. There's a lull at the end of the 1920's when things had stabilised, then loads 1931 to 1934 when a tax increase caused chaos in brewing.

Anyway, let's look at City of London's Pale Ale:



City of London Pale Ale quality 1922 - 1925


Year
Style
FG
OG
ABV
App. Atten-uation
Appearance
Flavour
score
Price


1922
PA
1006.3
1045.3
5.09
86.09%
grey
fair
1
8d


1922
PA
1008.5
1044
4.62
80.68%
bright
good
2
8d


1922
PA
1005
1046
5.36
89.13%
bright
good
2
8d


1922
PA
1008.2
1045.7
4.89
82.06%
bright
rather bitter, fair
1
8d


1923
PA
1009.4
1044.4
4.55
78.83%
bright
v. fair
2
7d


1923
PA
1009.4
1046.9
4.88
79.96%
fairly bright
sound
1
7d


1923
PA
1010.3
1045.8
4.62
77.51%
hazy
not quite sound
-1
8d


1923
PA
1007.8
1048.3
5.28
83.85%
piecy
poor
-1
8d


1923
PA
1009.6
1046.1
4.75
79.18%
hazy
thin
-1
8d


1923
PA
1009.4
1044.4
4.55
78.83%
bright
v fair
2
7d


1923
PA
1009.4
1046.9
4.88
79.96%
fairly bright
sound
1
7d


1925
PA
1010
1044
4.42
77.27%
fairly bright
v. fair
2
7d


1925
PA
1010
1044
4.42
77.27%
fairly bright
v fair
2
7d


Average
1008.7
1045.5
4.79
80.82%


1.00



Source:


Whitbread Gravity book held at the London Metropolitan Archives, document number LMA/4453/D/02/001



The contrast with the other beers of theirs we've looked at is considerable. Though clarity is a problem again, just five of thirteen samples were fully bright. Ten, however, got positive scores for flavour, with none worse than a minus one.

I can't help wondering if they brewed the Pale Ale themselves or, like Courage, got it from elsewhere.

The advice for time travellers is simple: stick to Bitter in City of London Brewery's pubs.

More... (http://barclayperkins.blogspot.com/2014/04/city-of-london-pale-ale-quality-1922.html)